[Passed] Motion to provide seed funding for B&C Exchange - a decentralized exchange built on the Peershares platform

Important Announcement as posted at https://bitcointalk.org/index.php?topic=1033773.msg11450787#msg11450787.

B&C Exchange has so far been unable to procure the minimum $200,000 required to develop a functioning exchange. In some ways continued delays reduce the chances of a successful outcome because the availability of the core team (Jordan, sigmike, erasmospunk and tomjoad) cannot be be assured in the future. These individuals need to pursue other opportunities if B&C Exchange is not prepared to pay them for their work now. So, in this sense it is imperative that funding be procured now so work can begin immediately. On the other hand, time brings with it greater opportunities to expose new potential investors to B&C. It means the funding opportunities increase with time but the probability of employing our proven team diminishes. This implies that a strategy that permits work to start now and funds to be raised later is optimal.

We have not taken this route because we feel it is inappropriate to spend peopleā€™s investment funds on a project that is clearly not yet funded to a degree that will permit the delivery of a functioning product that can bring a return on investment. Investment in such a scenario would be extremely risky, and we donā€™t want to risk our reputation by taking such a high risk of not bringing a return on investment to a broad set of investors from our community. However, very high risk ventures are suitable for a limited group of people such as venture capitalists with ample funds whose lifestyle will not be adversely effected by a failure of the venture. They routinely take very high risks for a chance of a very high rate of return. This is the sort of opportunity a partially funded B&C Exchange represents.

$80,000 has been procured from a small set of individuals who are certainly in a position to bear a total loss without any adverse consequences to their lifestyle, retirement, etc. These seed investors need to be rewarded for their high level of risk. Therefore, they will be given additional equity. They are purchasing 20% of the BKS for sale. Previously, giving half of the equity to BKS purchasers and half to NuShare holders was planned. This new plan will leave subsequent BKS purchasers unaffected, but it will reduce the equity of NuShare holders to 40% of initial total equity. This 10% of the total equity will be given to the seed investors, so they receive a total of 20% equity for their $80,000. This approach of using seed investment funds at the highest-risk beginning stages was proven to be successful in the development of Nu.

These funds will permit Jordan, erasmospunk, sigmike and tomjoad to begin work immediately. They will fund development for at least two months and perhaps three. The hope is that in that time interval the additional $120,000 needed to bring the project to a complete and workable state will be pledged and collected. Those investors will have considerably less risk because their funds will only be accepted if enough is pledged to complete the project. A marketing campaign will be conducted during the initial development phase to increase the chances of raising the needed additional $120,000. If the secondary funding drive fails and the project runs out of funding and is not completed, we wonā€™t have poisoned our relationships and reputation with a broad collection of investors because funds were only accepted from a tiny group well prepared to take extraordinary risk.

While we seek comment from the community and wish to gather the broadest support for the project by making any reasonable adjustments that may be suggested by the public, we wish to note moving forward only requires the approval of the seed investors. NuShare holders are involved because they will receive 40% equity, but they are being given that free of obligation, so their permission is not needed. We are not asking anything of NuShare holders, just as we are not asking anything of Bitcoin holders being given equity, although we believe the inclusion of these communities will bring tremendous benefit to B&C Exchange and we are indebted to these two communities for the gift of the code base we will fork as we begin development.

To summarize, initial equity will be now divided as follows:

Note that the funds pledged by second-round BlockShares purchasers will only be collected if $120,000 in pledges are reached. In combination with the $80,000 in committed capital from the seed investors, this would bring us to our goal of at least $200,000. Also note that the $55,310 already raised for second-round BlockShares purchases comes from the previous fundraising update totals.

For second-round BlockShare purchasers, here is the new sales schedule:

The current price is $4.08. Make a purchase by emailing bkssale@vistomail.com or sending a BitMessage to BM-2cTihATJ5FwJ7vWBwZmJjr55eFPFWBCmCQ. Please ensure you provide us with the information requested in the main announcement post.

Going into more detail, the cost of a given percentage of equity of second round BlockShare purchasers will not change in this updated plan. In order to maintain consistency in that regard, the number of BlockShares will need to be raised and their individual cost lowered. This is because the quantity of BlockShares given to NuShareholders is fixed: it was ~85,000 in the previous plan and will continue to be ~85,000 with this new proposal. However, the new plan reduces their equity percent to 40% from 50%. This requires the number of BlockShares given to seed investors, second round investors and Bitcoin holders be increased as shown above. Individuals who have already pledged funds will be eligible for the same percentage of BKS at the same price, but the quantity of BKS will be increased and the price per share lowered.

4 Likes

I don t quite understand well the situation.

You said previously that 131, 230 were raised.

Are those $80,000 provided by super investors part of the $131, 230?
If not, then the $200,000 are already reached.

Please clarify. Tks.

the 80k are the ones who are willing to wait and take the chance of losing all their funds if B&C does not succeed at the second auction. Presumably, the $51,230 of difference will submit their bids into the second auction, such that they still only need to raise something like $70,000. However, the $80k is guarenteed.

I donā€™t know, thatā€™s just what I understood.

1 Like

@Nagalim is correct. You can see in the bitcointalk chart that about $135,310 has been raised so far:

  • $80,000 from a small group of seed investors who will allow development to begin immediately.

  • $55,310 from everyone else who will be part of the ā€œSecond-round BlockShares Purchasersā€ group. These funds will only be collected if a minimum of $120,000 is pledged, bringing total funds to $200,000.

I just want to make sure of one thing. If I already pledged funds, I donā€™t have to repledge correct? Whatever somebody had previously planned to spend should still be the same?

All right. By the way bitcointalk is down.

not for me

Also, if Iā€™m going to post advertisements, Iā€™m trying to figure out what percentage I should use. If Iā€™m just going by the remaining $120,000, then we currently have 46% pledged, but if Iā€™m going off of the total $200,000, then itā€™s 67%. If Iā€™m going off 67% though, then saying this amount has been pledged is incorrect, since $80,000 of it has already been raised where the rest is simply pledged. I guess it kinda complicates the messaging and I was wondering what we should say in a shortened thread title.

Itā€™s good to see that B&C Exchange development can start thanks to the seed investors!

I have a question about the second round.
$55,310 are pledged, but not collected.

Is my understanding of this paragraph correct?

The pledged funds are calculated to an adjusted number of shares (based on the ā€œcurrent costā€ of $4.x)?

Say somebody had pledged $1,000.
Based on the ā€œprevious costā€ ($5.00 per BKS) that had corresponded to 200 BKS.
In the end the pledged amount is corresponding to a number of shares (245 BKS) based on the ā€œcurrent costā€ of $4.08, right?

2 Likes

Yes, you wonā€™t have to repledge if the total amount of USD you planned on spending hasnā€™t changed.

Perhaps the easiest way is to say that we have received commitments of 67% of our goal of $200,000. That term broadly captures both funds received and funds pledged.

Not quite. As the bitcointalk chart shows, if someone was confirmed at $5.00 previously, their new price would be $4.00. If they were confirmed at $5.10 (the old current price), they would now be at $4.08 (the new current price). The ratio of total USD bidded to equity percentage received does not change in this plan for second-round BlockShares purchasers. So, if $1000 was spent at the lowest price level, a user would have received 200 BKS before, and would receive 250 BKS after - a 25% increase in actual BKS, and a 0% increase in equity percentage of total BKS.

Iā€™m sorry this is still confusing me. How is the equity percentage of total BKS not increasing for the 2nd round pledges?

I was confused as well. Now my understanding leads to this answer:

because the total number of BKS has been increased by 25% and the price per BKS has been decreased by 25%.

In the end you receive the same share of the total BKS for the same amount of money.

2 Likes

Ah. Thatā€™s the only way it could have made sense but I did not notice the total amount of shares was increasing.

1 Like

This is the relevant part of the announcement. Apologies for any confusion, please let us know if that section can be worded better.

So, ā€œimmediatelyā€ - is development officially underway?

1 Like

I would like to point out that I believe there is a mistake in the matrix. We should still be in 1st phase of the 2nd Round Blockshare sale. There has been $55,000 worth of BKS sold in this phase while it requires $80,748 (20,187 BKS at $4) to proceed to the $4.08 per BKS phase. My understanding is that the ā€œSeed Investorsā€ do not also get a part of the secondary distribution also (unless they put more money into the sale).

1 Like

There are just a few issues that need to resolved for our Nu 2.0 release, particularly issue 167, 181, 188 and 199. When those are resolved, development will begin in earnest. The first iteration will consist of forking the Nu production blockchain into a testnet B&C Exchange blockchain. The next iteration will consist of the new voting types for B&C Exchange. The third iteration will focus on the first two or three messages unique to the B&C, such as the pairing of a BKS and BKC address and deposit public key lists. We will keep implementing new messages in the approximate order they would be used in until they are all done (so order fills will be done last).

5 Likes

One more question:

They will fund development for at least two months and perhaps three.

Where does the perhaps come from? Thatā€™s a 50% difference.

The uncertainty derives primarily from questions about how much work contributors will be able to complete and invoice for.

1 Like