Woah, this looks pretty bad. r/bitcoin has split into the following subredditsâŠ
Here are some comments from one of the moderators not involved in the censoringâŠ
[quote=jratcliff63367]"So, guys, Iâm a moderator in this forum, though I donât know for how long. It is late on a Saturday and I just logged in to see this mess. One of the forum moderators has been deleting hundreds of, what appear to me, to be perfectly valid comments.
Bitcoin-XT is NOT an alt-coin. It is an alternate client. Bitcoin-core is not some magical specially anointed copy of the code. That is deeply flawed and centralized thinking.
Bitcoin is supposed to be decentralized and whichever client the majority of the community runs will, naturally, organically, and by design, become the new rule set on the network.
I get that some people are strongly opposed to this fork. But, censoring discussion and incorrectly calling it an alt-coin is not the solution in my opinion.
For the record I havenât been removing any of these comments today and, after sharing my opinion in this post, I may be removed as one of the mods. Which is fine if that happens. This is a volunteer thing that I do only when Iâm already on the forum and have some free time.
But I wonât resign either. Sorry this is all such a mess right now."[/quote]
[quote=jratcliff63367][quote=BrazenAmberite]âAre you in communication with /u/theymos and the other mods which are engaging in the censorship? What is their justification? Do they realize that they are censoring an extremely important topic in bitcoinâs history just because of their own personal ideologies? Do they realize that they are going against the very core of redditâs rules?â[/quote]"Yes. Iâm in communication. Theymosâs position is that bitcoin-xt is an alt-coin, indistinguishable from dogecoin or litecoin. He is wrong, but he claims that is the reason for this. Dogecoin and litecoin operate on independent networks. No one submits a transaction to dogecoin and it shows up in the backlog for the bitcoin network.
Bitcoin-xt is an alternate client on the bitcoin network. This notion that there is only one pure authorized, authentic version of the bitcoin software is nonsense. That is centralized thinking. The correct bitcoin software is the ruleset being run by a majority of the network. Today that is bitcoin-core, but there is no reason to assume it can be the only valid software."[/quote]
